New Episodes every Monday
Every week, Whitney & Melissa travel from state to state, covering unsolved cases in an attempt to gain public awareness and encourage positive movement in the case.
Montana : Jeannette “Charlie” Atwater
Jeanette "Charlie" Rene Atwater was more than a tragic headline; she was a vibrant soul, a loving mother of three, and a generous spirit who left an indelible mark on those around her. On January 16th, 2000, her story took a dark turn as she was found lifeless in the trunk of her burning car. Despite the tireless efforts of law enforcement, her murder remains unsolved, leaving behind a haunting question of who could have committed such a heinous act against a woman known for her warmth and kindness. With each passing year, the mystery deepens, but the memory of Charlie lives on, etched in the hearts of those who loved her, and in the plea for justice that echoes through the decades.
Anyone with information is encouraged to reach out to the Yellowstone County Cold Case Unit at (406) 869-3530.
Missouri : Charles “Arlin” Henderson
Charles “Arlin” Leon Henderson was a typical energetic 11 year old boy. He enjoyed riding his bike, exploring the woods near his home and playing with friends. One summer evening, Arlin asked his mother if he could ride his bike to look for a friend to play with and she agreed but asked him to stay in their neighborhood not knowing that would be the last time she would see her son.
What happened to Arlin Henderson?
Mississippi : Jacqueline Levitz
Mary Jacqueline Levitz, born into a humble upbringing on a Louisiana cotton farm, navigated a life of remarkable twists and turns, marked by ambition and success. Her story took a dramatic turn when she met and married Ralph Levitz, a successful owner in the furniture industry. However, tragedy struck with Ralph's sudden illness, leading Jacqueline back to her roots in Mississippi. Yet, her return home was anything but smooth when she vanished from her home on November 18th, 1995, leaving behind a scene of violence and intrigue that continues to baffle investigators to this day.
Despite extensive searches and investigations, the fate of Mary Jacqueline Levitz remains shrouded in mystery, leaving behind a haunting question: What truly happened to this enigmatic woman of wealth and ambition?
Minnesota : Cassandra Rhines
Cassandra Rhines was a beautiful young woman who lived on the southwest side of Minneapolis. In June 1985, the then 19-year-old went missing after not showing up for her goddaughter’s birthday party. Her whereabouts would not be known for almost 30 years until her remains were discovered over 190 miles away.
What happened to Cassandra Rhines?
Michigan : Jessica Phelps
This week Melissa and Whitney dive into the tragic disappearance and murder of Jessica Phelps, a bright and spirited four-year-old girl who vanished from her home in Flint, Michigan, on July 1st, 1997. Despite extensive searches and public outcry, Jessica's whereabouts remained unknown for almost a year when her remains were found.
If you have any information about the murder of this little girl please contact Flint Police Department at (810) 237-6800.
Connecticut : Leah Ulbrich
Leah Baskins Ulrich was a dedicated mother from Hartford, Connecticut. In 1995, she was murdered in a horrifying incident. Despite investigations, the case remains unsolved. . Over the years, many witnesses came forward and potential suspects emerged, including a man with a criminal history of assaults on women. Despite renewed interest in 2019, technological advancements yielded no breakthroughs. Leah's children, now adults, advocate for justice, keeping their mother's memory alive. Law enforcement is seeking information, offering a $50,000 reward.
Colorado : Candace Hiltz
Candace, a promising 17-year-old with dreams of becoming a Supreme Court justice. Her life, however, takes a tragic turn on August 15, 2006, when she is brutally murdered in her home. The investigation unveils unsettling details, from a contentious encounter with law enforcement to the discovery of her beloved dog's murder, pointing to a disturbing sequence of events.They scrutinize the flawed investigation that initially focused on Candace's brother, James, who battles severe mental illness. The plot thickens with the shocking revelation of a police officer's misconduct. Who killed Candace Hiltz? Why did her family dog suffer a similar fate? And what secrets lie within the evidence mishandled by a law enforcement officer?
California : Humboldt County Five
In this episode, we delve into the haunting mysteries surrounding Humboldt County, known for its picturesque landscapes and, unfortunately, a dark underbelly linked to illegal marijuana cultivation. Melissa and Whitney explore the stories of the Humboldt County 5, focusing on the lives of Danielle Bertolini, Sheila Franks, Jennifer "Jade" Wilmer, Karen Mitchell, and Christine Walters. Each woman's narrative unfolds against the backdrop of the notorious Murder Mountain, where crime rates surged amidst the thriving marijuana industry. The episode meticulously details Danielle Bertolini's heartbreaking journey, the ominous disappearances of Sheila Franks and Jennifer Wilmer, the unsolved case of Karen Mitchell, and the perplexing vanishing act of Christine Walters.
What happened to these 5 women?
For more information about Danielle Bertonlini: Visit Murder, She Told
#California #HumboldtCounty5
Arkansas : Marquis Martin
This week Melissa and Whitney discuss the focus shifts from the picturesque town of Monticello, Arkansas, with its rich history and outdoor allure, to a chilling and unresolved case involving the disappearance and tragic death of Marquis Martin. Marquis went missing in February 2020, leading to a ransom text demanding money for his return. A month later Marquis was found dead with a gunshot wound to the head. The case becomes even more disturbing when the family receives a racist Snapchat image to leaves more questions than answers.
If you have any information about who kidnapped and murdered Marquis Martin, please call Arkansas State Police at 870-226-3713 or the Drew County Sheriff’s Department at 870-367-6211.
West Virginia : Brian Cook
Boone & Wyoming County West Virginia have more than a few secrets hidden in the mountains. Brian David Cook grew up in the area and even after doing his best to escape the small town life by joining the Marines, he managed to return and marry the love of his life. Brian was a hard worker and doting father but after his job required him to spend extended periods of time away from home, he fell ill to addiction. Regardless of his addiction, he remained present in his daughter’s life. On July 27th when he didn’t call, his ex wife Christina knew something was wrong.
What happened to Brian David Cook?
Washington : Leah Roberts
On a chilly March night in 2000, Leah leaves her home on an unexpeced and secret cross country trip to Washington State towards these mountains. Her abandoned and wrecked vehicle would be found at the base of the Cascade Mountains, with peculiar clues like blankets and scattered possessions, but no sign of Leah herself. Six years would pass without so much of a hint to Leah’s whereabouts when her car would be reexamination to revealed a cut wire, suggesting a deliberate wreck, along with evidence of male DNA on her clothing. The unanswered questions multiplied, leading to various theories, from foul play to a planned disappearance. Leah, a spirited young woman of 5'6" and 130 pounds, remains missing, leaving behind an enigma that haunts those who knew her. If you possess any information regarding Leah Roberts's disappearance, please contact the Whatcom County Sheriff's Office at 360-778-6600 or the Whatcom Communication Dispatch Center at 360-676-6711. The mystery of her fate endures, a puzzle yearning to be solved amidst the grandeur of Desolation Peak.
Virginia : Heidi Childs & David Metzler
Loved ones are still actively seeking answers in the 2009 murders of two Virginia Tech students, Heidi Childs and David Metzler. Heidi and David, both in their sophomore year at VT, were shot and killed between 8:25 p.m. and 10 p.m. on August 26, 2009. Their personal belongings were missing, but their case has seen renewed attention with a $100,000 reward and a dedicated website for tips. Authorities continue to appeal to the community for information that could bring justice to the victims and their families.
Vermont : The Bennington Triangle
The Bennington Triangle refers to a mysterious region in southwestern Vermont known for unexplained disappearances and odd occurrences. Encompassing towns like Bennington, Woodford, Shaftsbury, and Glastonbury, the triangle gained notoriety due to its perplexing events. Among these, the vanishing of Paula Welden, a college student hiking on the Long Trail in 1946, stands out. Numerous other disappearances followed, like James E. Tedford, who disappeared from a bus in 1949, and the case of eight-year-old Paul Jepson in 1950, who vanished while his mother was momentarily distracted. Beyond the disappearances, eerie lights in the sky, unexplained animal mutilations, and an unsettling ambiance have been reported. The term "Bennington Triangle" was coined by Joseph A. Citro, an author who delved into the mysteries. While various explanations have been offered, the enigmas remain, captivating those intrigued by the paranormal and unsolved mysteries.
Utah : Kimberly Evans
Kimberly Arbon Evans was a vibrant soul whose battle with depression took an unexpected turn in 1994. After a tragic loss, Kimberly struggled with depression. When she was found murdered 15 miles away near a popular hiking trail, the family was saddled with yet another tragedy.
Who killed Kimberly Evans?
If you also have heard anyone speaking about Kimberly, regardless of how small or insignificant you may feel the information is, please call 801.743.5850.
Texas : Juan Leon Laureles
his episode centers around the small town of Brownwood, Texas, known for its corruption and deeply rooted issues of racism and homophobia. The focus is on the murder of Juan Leon Laureles, who was a beloved member of his family and community. Leon was a caring and giving person, known for his passion for cooking and music. On the day of his murder, Leon's car was found engulfed in flames, and his body was discovered nearby. Leon was shot execution style. His niece, Arlene, and the rest of his family have been fighting for justice and accountability, trying to uncover the truth behind his cold case and the mishandling of the investigation. The town's culture of fear and silence makes it difficult for witnesses to speak up, leaving Leon's family in agony, longing for justice and closure.
Call Heart of Texas Crime Stoppers at (800) 222-8477 for tips, you can remain anonymous. A reward is currently available.
Tennessee : Melissa Chilton & Tiffany Campbell
Step back in time to 1996, a year filled with iconic films, sports triumphs, and musical wonders. Join us in Nashville, the enchanting "Music City," as we uncover a tale of tragedy and unsolved mystery. Two young women, Melissa Chilton and Tiffany Campbell, led unique lives with dreams and aspirations, embodying the spirit of this vibrant city. But their journey took a dark turn when they were brutally murdered at the Exotic Tan for Men salon. Despite years of relentless efforts by law enforcement, justice remains elusive. Join us as we navigate through the heart-wrenching twists and turns of this unsolved crime, delving into the lives of the victims and their families. We'll shed light on the impact of violence in Nashville and honor their memory with an empathetic and compassionate perspective. Help us seek justice for Melissa and Tiffany, and together, let's make a difference in the lives of those affected by crime.
If you have any information please contact Nashville Crime Stoppers at 615.74.CRIME.
South Dakota : Tina Marcotte
The disappearance of Tina Marcotte and the subsequent events surrounding her suspected killer, Tom Kueter, continues to captivate the public's attention, leaving unresolved questions for both their loved ones and the general public. Tina's case took a dramatic turn with the discovery of her remains, revealing a tragic murder. While the police have officially closed the case, doubts and intrigue surround Tom's death, with some questioning the suicide conclusion. Tina's daughter expressed peace and closure about her mother's fate but acknowledged the lingering mysteries. The article leaves readers with an eerie sense of unanswered questions and the haunting aura of an unresolved story that still beckons anyone with information to come forward.
If there is anything you know about Tina Marcotte or Tom Kueter, please contact the rapid city police department at 605-394-4131
Sources- https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Tina_Marcottehttps://www.city-data.com/crime/crime-Rapid-City-South-Dakota.htmlhttps://www.neighborhoodscout.com/sd/rapid-city/crimehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapid_City,_South_Dakotahttps://unsolved.com/gallery/tom-kueter/#:~:text=Tom%20Kueter%20was%20a%20forklift,workers%20noticed%20something%20was%20wrong.https://www.newspapers.com/image/527494425/?terms=tina%20marcotte%20&match=1https://www.newspapers.com/image/527465804/?terms=tina%20marcotte%20&match=1https://www.newspapers.com/image/527498313/?terms=tina%20marcotte%20&match=1
South Carolina : Silene “Erica” Eaddy
Silene "Erica" Eaddy, a teenager from South Carolina was brutally murdered in 2004. We explore her background growing up in the foster care system and her struggles with identity and rebellion. Silene's case takes a dark turn when she goes missing after sneaking out one evening, and her body is later discovered, showing signs of savage beating and being set on fire. Despite the efforts of law enforcement and a program that featured her case on playing cards in prisons, no substantial leads have emerged. Join us as we examine the limited information available, the theories surrounding her murder, and the ongoing search for justice in Silene's case. If you have any information, please contact the authorities or Crime Stoppers
Rhode Island : Kimberly Morse
The week's episode provides details about the unsolved murder case of Kimberly Sue Morse, a vibrant young woman from North Providence, Rhode Island. Kimberly was a goal-oriented individual known for her outgoing personality and love for fitness. In 2000, she was brutally attacked and murdered in her basement apartment. The crime scene indicated a personal connection between the killer and Kimberly, as valuable items, including gifts she received from club patrons, were taken. The police have explored multiple leads, including an ex-boyfriend who had a troubled relationship with Kimberly, but no suspects have been named or arrests made. Authorities received an anonymous tip in 2014 that led them to Michigan, but its significance remains undisclosed. The case continues to perplex investigators, with questions surrounding the motive, the identity of the perpetrator, and the physical evidence. Kimberly's family and friends seek closure and justice for her tragic death. Anyone with information is urged to contact the North Providence Police Department.
If you know anything about the murder of Kimberly Morse, please contact the North Providence Police Department at 401-233-1430 OR call their anonymous tip line at 401-719-1449.
Pennsylvania : Tonee Turner
In this episode, we delve into the story of Tonee Marie Turner, a 22-year-old artist and advocate from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Tonee's passion for art, dance, and community involvement made her a beloved figure in the Braddock neighborhood. However, tragedy struck when Tonee went missing under mysterious circumstances. Despite searches and efforts by her family, the case remains unsolved. We examine the theories surrounding her disappearance and the challenges faced in obtaining media coverage for missing persons, particularly women of color. Join us as we shed light on Tonee's story and seek justice for her and other missing individuals.